Arrest Made in Fatal Hit & Run

Using multiple means of evidence, the driver was identified as Alvin Paul who was driving a 2003 white Chevrolet when he veered off the road, hitting Shirley. Paul did not stop or report the crash and surveillance footage from a nearby business proved Paul as the driver. He later admitted to operating the vehicle carelessly.  At the time of the crash, Paul’s driver’s license was revoked from a prior DWI arrests. He has two prior DWI convictions and is currently on probation for the second DWI.

From the San Juan County Sheriff's Office:
Monday, September 8, 2025

On the morning of September 3rd, 2025, deputies responded to Road 5589 where a deceased male, identified as Alex Shirley, was found in a roadside ditch. The investigation revealed that Shirley was hit by a vehicle the evening before on September 2nd, 2025.

Using multiple means of evidence, the driver was identified as Alvin Paul who was driving a 2003 white Chevrolet when he veered off the road, hitting Shirley. Paul did not stop or report the crash and surveillance footage from a nearby business proved Paul as the driver. He later admitted to operating the vehicle carelessly.

 At the time of the crash, Paul’s driver’s license was revoked from a prior DWI arrests. He has two prior DWI convictions and is currently on probation for the second DWI. Deputies also discovered Paul was driving to a convenience store where he purchased alcohol at the time of the crash.

 Alvin Paul was arrested and charged with the following:

· Failing to Stop & Remain on Scene of an Accident (Death or Great Bodily Harm) (4th Degree Felony)

· Driving While License Revoked (DWI) (Misdemeanor) (2 COUNTS)

· Roadways Laned for Traffic (Failure to Maintain Traffic Lane) (Misdemeanor)

· Careless Driving (Careless, Inattentive, or Imprudent) (Misdemeanor)

More from Local News

  • Kirtland Man Charged with Woman's Killing

    On Monday, 11/9/2026, San Juan County Sheriff’s deputies were dispatched to a welfare check on Lovina Carpenter after a relative was worried she hadn’t heard from Ms. Carpenter since Saturday 11/7/2026. When deputies arrived on scene, they discovered Ms. Carpenter deceased in a shed on the property.

  • Floods Impact SW Colorado Highways

    Recent flooding washed out roads and a bridge, causing full closures on common routes and significant repair delays along key corridors.

  • 2026 Mid-term Election results

    Results from the contested races in San Juan County, NM, in the 2026 midterm elections held on Tuesday, November 3, 2026. These results are considered unofficial until certified by the San Juan County canvassing board.

  • Gov. to Visit Flood-Stricken San Juan County

    The governor’s visit was carefully scheduled to give first responders, law enforcement and emergency vehicles ample time to complete rescues and other emergency work during the flooding. Now that the floodwaters are receding and initial damage assessments are underway, the Governor will survey the disaster zone and work to get families the help they need. 

  • National Guard, State Police carry out rescues as historic flooding hits San Juan County

    New Mexico Governor Lujan Grisham preparing request for federal disaster declaration

  • Woman's Husband Arrested for Kirtland Killing

    Through the course of the investigation, detectives discovered that Lauren Patterson’s husband, Jess Patterson, had previously resided in California and had been arrested at least 6 times for domestic violence in that state and had been arrested in July 2026 in New Mexico for battering Ms. Patterson. An autopsy revealed Ms. Patterson suffered multiple broken bones, bruising, and internal injuries.

On KSJE Now:

KSJE Radio App

Get the KSJE Radio App

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play

Today's Weather

  • Farmington, NM

    Sunny intervals

    High: 61°F | Low: 39°F

  • Durango, CO

    Sunny intervals

    High: 54°F | Low: 30°F

  • Shiprock, NM

    Sunny

    High: 59°F | Low: 37°F

  • Cortez, CO

    Sunny

    High: 59°F | Low: 34°F

  • Santa Fe, NM

    Sunny intervals

    High: 54°F | Low: 34°F